For each commerce acquisition like Joe Carter, Josh Donaldson and Jose Bautista, the Blue Jays have made offers that didn’t fairly work out of their favor.
Shrewd strikes have introduced the Toronto Blue Jays to the highest of the baseball world earlier than.
The acquisition of Joe Carter and Roberto Alomar paved the way in which to back-to-back World Collection titles. They signed getting older veterans like Jack Morris, Dave Winfield, and Paul Molitor who had been chasing one last shot at glory of their careers.
Josh Donaldson was an American League MVP in Toronto. In addition they obtained Jose Bautista in a deal for a participant who later grew to become a bullpen catcher.
However not each transfer has turned out within the Blue Jays’ favor. For each franchise-changing commerce, free-agent signing, or entrance workplace shuffle, there have been some head-scratching choices within the membership’s 43-year historical past.
Listed below are the 10 largest choices the Blue Jays in all probability want that they had again.
Blue Jays mistake No. 10: Buying and selling Noah Syndergaard for R.A. Dickey
Knuckleballs are notoriously unpredictable. They dance, dart and dip in each doable path. The pitch is topic to wild swings in effectiveness. Even the pitcher whose fingers launch the ball has nearly no management over the place it finally ends up.
The identical will be mentioned of knuckleball pitchers, none extra so than R.A. Dickey. Dickey made his Main League debut again in 2001 and moved between 4 groups by 2012, solely as soon as profitable greater than 10 video games in a season. Then, in 2012 on the age of 37, he went 20-6 with a 2.73 ERA for the New York Mets, a profession yr that led to him profitable the NL Cy Younger Award.
A better take a look at his numbers reveals simply what an excellent season Dickey had in 2012. He walked 2.08 batters per 9 innings, a stable quantity for any starter however unbelievable for a knuckleballer. He struck out eight.9 per 9 innings after solely as soon as earlier than in his profession being above six Ok/9, and that got here 9 years earlier. He was the one pitcher to throw a knuckleball that season, utilizing the pitch 85.four p.c of the time.
The Mets had a call to make following the season. Was Dickey’s yr an aberration, or may he repeat it going ahead? They selected the previous, and on Dec. 17 they shipped him to the Toronto Blue Jays in a package deal that included prospects Noah Syndergaard and Travis d’Arnaud.
The Blue Jays had simply made a blockbuster take care of Miami for Jose Reyes, Mark Buehrle, and Josh Johnson. Common Supervisor Alex Anthopoulos had a win-now philosophy. As promising as Syndergaard was, he was years away from enjoying within the Majors. Dickey was the reigning Cy Younger winner who may step into the rotation immediately.
Dickey remained a stable starter with the Blue Jays, profitable 28 video games with a three.97 ERA in his first two seasons. He was a key a part of the 2015 membership that went to the ALCS and made 29 begins in 2016 however was left off the postseason roster. However he was no Syndergaard.
From 2015, the yr he made his Main League debut, to 2018, Syndergaard had the fourth-lowest ERA amongst beginning pitchers, behind solely Clayton Kershaw, teammate Jacob deGrom and Max Scherzer. His common fastball velocity led all starters at 97.6 mph. And, after 5 years within the large leagues, he’s nonetheless simply 27, greater than a decade youthful than Dickey was when the Blue Jays acquired him.
In 4 seasons in Toronto, Dickey completed with a 49-52 document and a four.05 ERA in 130 begins. His stroll fee jumped to 2.9, whereas his strikeouts declined to six.6. He was good, however by no means once more was he nice like in 2012. He final pitched within the Majors in 2017. Syndergaard, in the meantime, even after Tommy John surgical procedure earlier this yr, nonetheless has a few years of greatness forward of him.